COVID-19 Related Updates to Bankruptcy Courtroom Policies and Procedures
Most bankruptcy courts have altered their practices and procedures in light of COVID-19. Below is a summary of the changes to practices and procedures in the United States Bankruptcy Courts for the Southern District of New York, the Eastern District of New York, the District of Delaware, and the Southern District of Texas. We will aim to update this report as courts revise their procedures, but given the fluidity of the situation and the frequency of COVID-19-related updates, please also consult the relevant court’s website.
United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York
On April 9, 2020, the Bankruptcy Court issued General Order M-545, effective immediately, which provides that for individual chapter 7, 11, 12, and 13 cases:
- An original signature is no longer necessary to electronically file a document bearing that signature, provided that, before filing, the CM/ECF user verifies with the signer that the signer has received the entire document to be filed, and:
- “has obtained express written permission from the signer to affix the signer’s signature to the document and has retained a hard copy of such written permission;
- has obtained in his or her possession at the time of the filing an image, photograph, or other facsimile of the signer’s signature on the signature page of the document and has retained a hard copy of the image, photograph, or facsimile; or
- has obtained the signer’s digital signature via any commercially available digital signature software that provides signature authentication; and has instructed the signer to send or deliver the original signed paper(s) to the CM/ECF user as soon as is practicable”.
- Creditors providing temporary suspensions of mortgage payments to debtors in this Court should file a Notice of Temporary Forbearance, which can be found attached to General Order M-545. Creditor-debtor communications about forbearance and other statements during the forbearance period do not violate the automatic stay. Finally, loss mitigation orders are not required for debtors to enter into forbearance agreements, but the Court’s Loss Mitigation Program Procedures are available to the parties if they are unable to come to a consensual resolution within 14 days of the initial request.
- Deadlines under the Loss Mitigation Program Procedures or Student Loan Mediation Program, provided that they have not expired by March 16, 2020, are extended to July 1, 2020. The extension does not impact the parties’ ability to agree on a forbearance of a mortgage loan, per M-545; consensually resolve “an individual debtor’s obligations on a mortgage of residential real property;” or consensually resolve an individual debtor’s student loan obligations.
- Trustees will be allowed to accept evidence that they conclude to be appropriate to establish the existence of such document (i.e., PDF scan, photograph, or screenshot).
- M-545 will expire on the earlier of (a) a more recent Order from this Court addressing the same issues, or (2) July 1, 2020.
- The Court also notes that it will “consider requests for similar relief” if movants “can demonstrate exigent circumstances based on the COVID-19 virus pandemic.”
Prior to General Order M-545, the Bankruptcy Court issued General Order M-543 on March 20, 2020, which provides that:
- All hearings and conferences scheduled for the Manhattan, White Plains, and Poughkeepsie Divisions of the Bankruptcy Court will be held telephonically, and parties interested in appearing in person should file or submit an appropriate motion or request. Parties can request adjournments of hearings or conferences by filing a motion or request detailing the request and basis, as per the Bankruptcy Judge’s procedures for requesting adjournments. Anyone intending to appear at or attend a telephonic hearing or conference must refer to the Bankruptcy Judge’s guidelines for telephonic appearances and use Court Solutions LLC. The telephonic service is free of charge for pro se parties and chapter 7 and 13 trustees.
- Parties should contact their individual Bankruptcy Judge or courtroom deputy/law clerk to determine whether upcoming evidentiary hearings and trials will proceed as planned, and to discuss procedures and technology to be used at the evidentiary hearing. Methods for contacting the Judge or deputies may vary by Judge (i.e., phone call or email).
- Bankruptcy Court personnel will be using tools available through Court Solutions to record telephonic hearings, conferences, and trials. Those recordings will be the official record. Transcripts can be ordered and corrected as they were before General Order M-54
- The Bankruptcy Court’s three Divisions are still open for all other business. “Clerk’s Office personnel are available by telephone, mail will be received, and the intake desks will remain open to receive pro se filings.”
- Information about using CourtSolutions can be found here.
Other relevant COVID-19 developments include:
- On April 23, 2020, the Court implemented General Order M-546, which adopts temporary amendments to Interim Rule 1020 to account for the CARES Act. The change adds a new definition of ‘debtor’ for eligibility purposes for proceeding under subchapter V of chapter 11. The amendment terminates one year after the date of the enactment of the CARES Act.
- Effective March 13, 2020, all in-person chapter 7, 12, and 13 section 341 meetings scheduled through April 10, 2020 are continued to a later date to be determined, and section 341 meetings cannot proceed during this period except through telephonic or other alternative means that does not require personal appearance by debtors. Meetings that have already been scheduled as telephonic may proceed as scheduled.
- Per General Order M-542, signed on March 17, 2020, while the Court remains open for business, access to the Bankruptcy Court building will be restricted to types of persons listed in the order
United States Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of New York
In the Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of New York:
- All hearings will be held by phone and recorded by the Court until further notice. Other recordings of those telephonic hearings may not be made.
- For more guidance on procedures for participating in telephonic hearings, please check the individual judge’s COVID-19 national emergency procedures, available here on the left-hand side.
- Where necessary, PDF documents can be sent to the Court at [email protected]. The Court requests that you include your full name, address, phone number, and email address along with the papers so that the Court may contact you should it need additional information.
- For the duration of the National Emergency, cash will not be accepted for purposes of filing fees.
- Pro se filers should use postal money orders or cashier’s checks, made payable to Clerk, US Bankruptcy Court, and should send their documents to the Court by mail. Alternatively, they may send PDF documents to the Court’s electronic drop box. If a pro se filer must come to the courthouse, they should use the night depository located in the lobbies of the Brooklyn and Central Islip Courthouses during regular business hours. Further, if the Clerk’s Office is closed, papers that are not filed electronically can be filed by depositing them in the night depository in the courthouse lobby of the Court where the case is pending. Documents submitted via night depository will be deemed as filed as of the exact time and date stamped on the papers.
- All in-person chapter 7, 12, and 13 section 341 meetings scheduled through April 10, 2020 are continued to a later date to be determined, and section 341 meetings may not proceed during this time unless through telephone or other means not requiring personal appearance. Meetings that were already scheduled as telephonic meetings are proceeding as planned.
- For telephonic 341 meetings of creditors, testifying debtors and counsel should call in promptly through the number and passcode made available on the docket three days before the meeting, remain on mute until the case is called, and ensure that the debtor has read the Bankruptcy Information Sheet before the meeting. Debtor and counsel are also “required to email the trustees with an imaged copy of the debtor’s photo identification and proof of the debtor’s social security number.” These must be provided through a secure method, such as encrypted mail. Following the telephonic meeting, a Declaration Regarding Administration of Oath and Confirmation of Identity and Social Security Number form should be completed.
United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware
As of April 28, 2020, visitors to the Bankruptcy Court, including litigants and attorneys, must wear a mask or face covering when in public areas of the Court and when interacting with the Court’s staff.
The Bankruptcy Court issued a Second Amended Order Governing the Conduct of Hearings Due to Coronavirus Due to Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19), which supersedes and replaces the previous March 16, 2020 General Order and March 31, 2020 Amended Order, and provides that:
- Court Hearings that are not time sensitive will be continued to a later, to-be-determined date by the presiding judge on or after May 18, 2020. Whether a Court Hearings is time-sensitive will be determined by the presiding judge.
- All Court Hearings prior to May 18, 2020 will be held telephonically and/or by video conference unless otherwise ordered by the presiding judge.
- The method for submitting evidence for telephonic and/or video conference Court Hearings held before May 18, 2020, will be determined by the presiding judge on a case-to-case basis.
- Chapter 13 confirmation hearings scheduled for April 27, 2020, and the Chapter 13 motions calendar scheduled for April 28, 2020, will be held telephonically.
On April 20, 2020, the Court issued an Interim Order in light of the CARES Act, which “provides a new definition of ‘debtor’ for determining eligibility to proceed under subchapter V of chapter 11.” The rule was amended to reflect the change and will remain in effect for one year after the date of the enactment of the CARES Act.
Some further procedural changes and updates in light of COVID-19 include:
- No in-person public access to the Bankruptcy Court’s Clerk’s Office. The Office will remain open through (1) telephone, (2) email access, and (3) the drop boxes located in the lobby of the court house. CM/ECF also continues to be available for electronic filing.
- As of March 18, 2020, all hearings at the Bankruptcy Court are being held telephonically via CourtCall. Where video conferences are necessary, the Court is using Skype for Business.
- As of March 16, 2020, the Bankruptcy Court is no longer accepting hand deliveries of documents, and has accordingly modified several relevant local rules via Interim Order available here.
- From March 26, 2020, until May 31, 2020, the Court has temporarily suspended the requirement that attorneys obtain a debtor’s original, physical signature before electronic filing where necessary, if they have either “(a) obtained the debtor’s digital signature via any commercially available digital signed software that signature authentication and maintains a copy of the digitally signed document(s) in the debtor’s case file; or (b) obtains express written permission (including electronic mail) from the debtor to affix the debtor’s signature to the document(s), and maintains a hard copy thereof in the file.”
- As of March 27, 2020, anticipating an increase in SBRA cases given the CARES Act’s raising of the eligibility cap, the Court has assigned, at random, all chapter 11, Subchapter V cases to either the Hon. Brendan Linehan Shannon or the Hon. John T. Dorsey.
- As of March 13, 2020, “all in-person chapter 7, 12, and 13 section 341 meetings scheduled through April 10, 2020 are continued until a later date to be determined,” and section 341 meetings may only proceed during this period through telephonic or other alternative means that does not require an in-person appearance by the debtor.
United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas
The Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas posted an emergency protocol (available here as 2020-04) for addressing COVID-19-related concerns, which it then invoked on March 26, 2020 for all bankruptcy courts in the District. The protocol provides that:
- Hearings may still be scheduled or rescheduled by the Court to be heard during this period. Such hearings will be conducted electronically. The Court may also reschedule hearings it previously canceled to be conducted in the ordinary course. Hearings may be held either by the Judge assigned to the case, or by any other Bankruptcy Judge.
- Notice of chapter 13 panel hearings will take place through a notice posted by the chapter 13 trustees on the trustee’s website. Unless otherwise ordered, “chapter 13 panel hearings will only be heard if there is a statutorily imposed deadline for the conduct of the hearing,” and the trustees “will post a hearing calendar that contains only matters with statutorily imposed deadlines.”
- “Notice of all other hearings will be entered on the docket of the case by the Clerk in each case in which a hearing is scheduled by the Court.”
- Parties and counsel are responsible for keeping up to date with the Court’s website and their case dockets. Electronic attendance at hearings will be required if said individual was otherwise required to appear in the hearing before the protocol period. Personal attendance at electronic hearings will not be permitted, except as ordered by the Court. Instead, the Court is conducting electronic hearings through audio and video communication.
- Witnesses must appear by both audio and video connection. The oath will be administered over the audio connection. The Court may allow parties-in-interest to utilize the Join.me website to present documents or other presentations, in which case the Court will allow the party to become a “presenter of a presentation.”
- “Motions for Relief from the automatic stay must be self-calendared for hearing on the Court’s published available dates,” which will be conducted electronically. Aside from such motions or as otherwise ordered, hearings may not be self-calendared by any filing or notice that is filed during the protocol period. “If a hearing is required during the Protocol Period, the person seeking the hearing must file a motion for emergency consideration and request the hearing by contacting the appropriate person” on a list labeled Exhibit C on the Court’s website, containing contact information for the relevant individuals. If a hearing is required after the Protocol Period, the person seeking the hearing should contact the appropriate person from Exhibit C after the Protocol Period ends.
- To request an emergency hearing during this time, in addition to complying with the local rules, an email should be sent to the Judge’s staff member and to the Emergency Request Hotline
- “Section 341 meetings of creditors will be conducted electronically”
- “Statutory deadlines remain in effect” while deadlines imposed by the Court, local rule, and by the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure are tolled for the Protocol Period. The toll is calculated by adding the length of the Protocol Period to the original deadline.
- Finally, Judges may vary the protocol on a case-by-case basis, and the protocol itself is subject to amendment
Other Orders issued in response to COVID-19 explain that:
- “All in-person chapter 7, 11, 12, and 13 section 341 meetings scheduled through April 10, 2020, are continued until a later date to be determined by the United States Trustee. Absent special circumstances, section 341 meetings may not proceed during this period except through telephonic or other alternative means not requiring personal appearance by debtors. Appropriate notice will be provided to parties in accordance with bankruptcy law and rules. Meetings already noticed as telephonic meetings may proceed as scheduled.”
- The Court is modifying its requirement of “wet signatures” such that documents “electronically signed utilizing a commercially available electronic signing technology (such as DocuSign) that (a) maintains an audit trail that allows the filing attorney to obtain the identification of the signer’s computer or device from the commercial provider; and (b) complies with the requirements of the United States ESIGN Act” will be accepted in place of “wet signatures.” The Court also continues to accept “wet signatures.”
- From March 23, 2020, through May 31, 2020, Paragraphs 7 and 8.B of the Bankruptcy Rule 2016(b) Disclosure and Application for Approval of Fixed Fee Agreement is amended to allow for audio or video conference for the “in person meeting,” with preference for a video conference. If the required meeting does not take place in person, “Debtor’s counsel must file a certificate with the Clerk identifying the alternative method of meeting (including the software program utilized); the date and time the meeting was conducted; and if audio conferencing was used, the reason why a video conference was not conducted.”
 General Order M-545, Bankr. S.D.N.Y., April 9, 2020.
 General Order M-543, Bankr. S.D.N.Y., March 20, 2020.
 General Order M-543, In re: Adoption of Temporary Amendment to Interim Bankruptcy Rule 1020 Corresponding to the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, Bankr. S.D.N.Y., April 23, 2020.
 UST Notice re: Rescheduling 341 Meetings, http://www.nysb.uscourts.gov/news/ust-notice-re-rescheduling-341-meetings (last visited April 2, 2020).
 General Order M-542, Bankr. S.D.N.Y., March 17, 2020.
 Home page, Bankr. E.D.N.Y., https://www.nyeb.uscourts.gov/ (last visited April 8, 2020).
 Judges’ Procedures, Bankr. E.D.N.Y., https://www.nyeb.uscourts.gov/node/52 (last visited April 8, 2020).
 Clerk’s Office and Pro Se Filings During National Emergency (COVID-19), Bankr. E.D.N.Y., March 24, 2020.
 Clerk’s Office and Pro Se Filings During National Emergency (COVID-19), Bankr. E.D.N.Y., March 24, 2020.
 Notice from the United States Trustee Continuing All In-Person Section 341 Meetings through April 10, 2020 in the Districts of Connecticut, New York and Vermont, https://www.nyeb.uscourts.gov/news/notice-united-states-trustee-continuing-all-person-section-341-meetings-through-april-10-2020 (last visited April 8, 2020).
 Telephonic 341 meeting of creditors during Covid-19 Emergency: Instructions for Testifying Debtors and Counsel, Office of the United States Trustee, E.D.N.Y., https://www.nyeb.uscourts.gov/sites/nyeb/files/Covid-19-General-Instructions.pdf (last visited April 8, 2020).
 In Re: Use of Face Mask/Coverings In Public Areas of the District And Bankruptcy Courts, Standing Order, Bankr. D. Del., April 28, 2020.
 In Re: Second Amended Order Governing the Conduct of Hearings Due to Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19), Bankr. D. Del., April 20, 2020.
 In Re: Adoption of Cares Act Changes To Interim Bankruptcy Rule 1020, Bankr. D. Del., April 20, 2020.
 COVID-19 – Emergency Clerk’s Office Procedures, Notice Regarding Court Operations during COVID-19 Virus Outbreak, https://www.deb.uscourts.gov/news/covid-19-emergency-clerks-office-procedures (last visited April 2, 2020).
 In Re: Cessation of Hand Deliveries, Bankr. D. Del., March 31, 2020.
 In Re: Order Temporarily Suspending Requirement to Obtain Original Signatures from Debtors for Electronic Filings, Bankr. D. Del., March 26, 2020.
 In Re: Order Assigning Certain Judges for Cases Under the Small Business Reorganization Act, Bankr. D. Del., March 27, 2020.
 Delaware 341 Meeting Notice, Important Notice from the United States Trustee for Regions 3 and 9 Regarding 341 Meetings, http://www.deb.uscourts.gov/news/delaware-341-meeting-notice (last visited April 2, 2020).
 In Re: Invocation of Emergency Protocol, Bankr. S.D. Tex., March 26, 2020.
 In Re: Adoption of Contingency Plan to Address Possible Public Health Limitations on Court Operations, Bankr. S.D. Tex., March 9, 2020.
 In Re: Implementation of Alternative Procedures for Conducting Creditor Meetings under 11 U.S.C. § 341, Bankr. S.D. Tex., March 16, 2020.
 In Re: Authorization of Electronic Signatures, Bankr. S.D. Tex., March 19, 2020.
 In Re: Temporary Authorization of an In Person Meeting Requirement by Alternative Means, Bankr. S.D. Tex., March 24, 2020.